Hotel Pony Island Inn, Ocracoke, United States

70 photos

Pony Island Inn - Ocracoke

$$$$

Overview

Pony Island Inn Ocracoke, located within a 300-metre distance of Teach's Hole Blackbeard Exhibit Gift Shop and 12 minutes' walk from Anchorage Marina, features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool for guests to take a dip in. Highlights at the inn include Wi-Fi throughout the property.

Location

This property is situated about 130 km from Sirnak Serafettin Elci airport and a short walk from Ocracoke Alive's Deepwater Theater. Outer Banks National Scenic Byway is 15 minutes' walk away, and Waves is 70 km from the hotel. A 20-minute stroll will take you to Springer's Point Preserve.

Rooms

Pony Island Inn has 40 rooms appointed with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, as well as self-catering options such as tea and coffee making equipment. They come with a tub, a separate toilet, and a shower along with such comforts as toiletries and bath sheets. Guests can take advantage of views of the pool.

Eat & Drink

Sample Italian specialities at Sorellas Pizza & Pasta located 5 minutes' walk from this Ocracoke hotel.

Leisure & Business

A picnic area and a community pool are available for additional fees.

Good to know

Check-in/Check-out

from 15:00-18:00

until 11:00

Building

Number of rooms:40

Former name

pony island motel

Price calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Rooms and availability

66 photos

Queen Suite

Max:

4 persons
Bed options:

1 Queen-size bed

room details +

44 photos

Deluxe Double Room

Max:

4 persons
Bed options:

1 Double bed

room details +

77 photos

Double Room

Max:

4 persons
Bed options:

1 Queen-size bed1 Double bed

Pool view
Shower
Heating

room details +

Show 2 more room typesLess

Facilities

Main facilities

Free Wi-Fi

Free parking

Luggage storage

24-hour services

Food/ Drinks

Picnic area/ Tables

Swimming pool

Seasonal outdoor pool

Flat-screen TV

Kitchen facilities

Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Services

Housekeeping

Dining

Picnic area/ Tables

Business

Fax/Photocopying

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Sun loungers
Sun terrace
Shallow end

Room view

Pool view

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Garden furniture
Tea and coffee facilities
Dining table

Bathroom

Free toiletries

Self-catering

Cookware/ Kitchen utensils

Media

Flat-screen TV

Room decor

Parquet floor

Show all facilitiesHide facilities

Essential information about Pony Island Inn

💵 Lowest room price	577 NZ$
📏 Distance to centre	700 m
✈️ Distance to airport	126.2 km
🧳 Nearest airport	Sirnak Serafettin Elci, NKT

Location

Address

The address has been copied.

785 Irvin Garrish Hwy, Ocracoke, North Carolina, United States, NC 27960

Map view

785 Irvin Garrish Hwy, Ocracoke, North Carolina, United States, NC 27960

City landmarks
Nearby
Restaurants
Hotels nearby

Lighthouse

Ocracoke Lighthouse

1.2 km

Museum

Ocracoke Preservation Museum

1.3 km

Cemetery

British Cemetery

1.2 km

2 Irvin Garrish Highway

Outer Banks National Scenic Byway

1.2 km

Gallery

Down Creek Gallery

940 m

64 British Cemetery Rd.

Over the Moon

1.0 km

100 yards NE of Pilottown Circle Between the parking lot & the coast line.

Fort Ocracoke Monument

1.4 km

Marina

Anchorage Marina

980 m

148 Maurice Ballance Rd

Ocracoke Community Ball Field

660 m

Irvin Garrish Hwy

Ocracoke Wave Runners

720 m

104 Loop Rd

Springer's Point Preserve

1.7 km

Horsepen Point

1.3 km

Silver Lake

940 m

NC-12

Ocracoke Watermen's Exhibit

940 m

104 Loop Rd

Springers Point Trail Access

1.3 km

Springers Point

1.8 km

Beach

Ocracoke Beach

2.1 km

First Hammock Hills

4.1 km

Museum

Teach's Hole Blackbeard Exhibit

260 m

Ocracoke Island

380 m

Restaurant

Eduardo's Taco Stand

230 m

Restaurant

Helios' Hideaway

430 m

The Ocracoke Harbor Inn

9.0 Perfect | 75 reviews627 m

Villas Of Hatteras Landing By Kees Vacations

27.4 km

The Inn On Pamlico Sound

9.2 Perfect | 54 reviews40.8 km

Outer Banks Motel - Village Accommodations

7.8 Very good | 47 reviews43.9 km

Cape Pines Motel

8.9 Great | 84 reviews44.0 km

Yellowfin & Zebrafish

44.6 km

Clownfish & Cobia

44.6 km

Bluefish #2A-Cac

44.6 km

Swell Motel

9.0 Perfect | 29 reviews44.8 km

Cape Hatteras Motel

8.2 Great | 101 reviews45.2 km

Beaufort Hotel

9.1 Perfect | 81 reviews74.2 km

Pecan Tree Inn

10.0 Perfect | 51 reviews76.3 km

Inlet Inn Nc

9.2 Perfect | 49 reviews76.4 km

Bask Hotel At Big Rock Landing

8.7 Great | 82 reviews80.0 km

Reviews of Pony Island Inn

8.2 /10

Great

Verified reviews

All reviews shown are from real guest experiences. Only travelers who have booked a stay with us can submit a review. We verify reviews according to our guidelines and publish all reviews, positive or negative.

Guest reviewsWrite a Review

missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

A

Andrew

United States

left 2 reviews

Wrote a review on 18 Sept

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location8.0

Rooms9.0

Service9.0

Dining6.0

9.0

clean room

spacious storage

pool area

limited dining

great stay but minor issues

I was very impressed with how clean my room was it felt even better kept than many high-end hotels. The spacious courtyard side room with two double beds offered ample storage, which made it easy to keep my belongings organized. The pool and deck were well maintained, providing a nice retreat after a day out. Watching the sunset from the outdoor area was a highlight of my evening.

The only downside was the limited dining options nearby.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20243 nightsFamily with childrenStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

F

Frank

United States

left 3 reviews

Wrote a review on 14 Sept

Great

Recommends the hotel

Location8.0

Rooms8.0

Service8.0

Dining6.0

8.0

cozy room

outdoor pool

comfortable beds

breakfast quality

The room was cozy and perfect for our family, especially loved the comfy beds and the small fridge for snacks. The kids really enjoyed the seasonal outdoor pool and the sun loungers by the poolside. Just a heads up, the breakfast could use some improvement, but overall we had a great time! ☀️

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20242 nightsFamily with childrenStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

J

Jessica

United States

left 12 reviews

Wrote a review on 30 Aug

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location10.0

Rooms10.0

Service9.0

Dining9.0

10

spacious room

comfortable beds

outdoor seating

I loved the spacious room with a kitchenette. The comfortable beds made for a great night's sleep. Outdoor seating offered perfect views of the sunset. Fresh towels were always available. Easy access to nearby restaurants was a plus. 🌅

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20241 nightCoupleStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

J

James

United States

left 1 review

Wrote a review on 27 Aug

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location10.0

Rooms10.0

Service10.0

Dining9.0

10

outdoor seating

cozy atmosphere

laid-back vibe

handrails

bathroom safety

The cozy outdoor seating area was delightful! I enjoyed relaxing under the cedar trees, listening to the summer cicadas while sipping my tea. It had just the right laid-back vibe, making it so welcoming and easy to enjoy.

Could use additional handrails in the bathroom.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20246 nightsCoupleStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

R

Richard

United States

left 9 reviews

Wrote a review on 23 Aug

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location10.0

Rooms10.0

Service9.0

Dining9.0

10

outdoor seating

kitchenette

The room was spacious with a kitchenette, great for storing snacks. Loved the comfortable beds and the outdoor seating area! Watching the evening sun over a cold drink was a highlight.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20241 nightCoupleStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

D

Daniel

United States

left 5 reviews

Wrote a review on 20 Aug

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location10.0

Rooms9.0

Service9.0

Dining9.0

9.0

spacious room

kitchenette

dirty floors

cleaning issues

The best part of my stay was the spacious room with a kitchenette! 🍽️ It made snacking easy. While everything else was nice, the wood floors could've used a better clean during our stay. Would def return!

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20246 nightsFamily with childrenDeluxe Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

M

Malcolm

United States

left 1 review

Wrote a review on 15 Aug

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location10.0

Rooms9.0

Service9.0

Dining7.0

9.0

kitchenette

cleanliness

breakfast options

overpriced dining

Comfortable stay with great location

I had a lovely stay for four nights in a room with a kitchenette, which made it convenient to prepare snacks. The location was perfect, close to beaches and restaurants, and I appreciated the cleanliness of the room. However, the breakfast options could use some improvement, as they felt overpriced and lacking in variety.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20244 nightsCoupleQueen Room With Pool View
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

C

Chuck

United States

left 1 review

Wrote a review on 10 Aug

Perfect

Recommends the hotel

Location10.0

Rooms9.0

Service9.0

Dining5.0

9.0

water pressure

Great match for a quick break in Ocracoke with best value. The water pressure in the shower was surprisingly weak, making rinsing hair tricky. Make sure to check the shower pressure in your room before settling in!

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20243 nightsFamily with childrenStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

F

Frank

United States

left 6 reviews

Wrote a review on 09 Aug

Nice

Doesn't recommend the hotel

Location8.0

Rooms6.0

Service7.0

Dining5.0

6.0

handy kitchenette

outdated cramped room

The kitchenette was handy, but the room felt outdated and cramped.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20243 nightsCoupleStandard Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

B

Billy

United States

left 2 reviews

Wrote a review on 04 Aug

Great

Recommends the hotel

Location9.0

Rooms8.0

Service8.0

Dining8.0

8.0

clean room

weak shower pressure

The location was great with easy access to

all the local attractions. Our room was clean and spacious. However, we did encounter some issues with the shower water pressure, which made it difficult to rinse off properly. Overall, it was a pleasant stay.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: July 20242 nightsFamily with childrenDeluxe Double Room
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

L

Lisa

United States

left 16 reviews

Wrote a review on 27 Apr

Very good

Recommends the hotel

Location9.0

Rooms7.0

Service8.0

Dining5.0

7.0

cozy queen room

easy bike access

pony island inn was nestled in a lovely spot, making it easy to explore the island. the queen room with pool view was cozy and allowed us to unwind after biking around town. okracoke's charm shone even in the off-season, and we loved renting bikes to get around!

100% recommend

0 Helpful

Date of stay: March 20241 nightFamily with childrenQueen Room With Pool View
missingPony Island Inn - Ocracoke

K

Karen

United States

left 18 reviews

Wrote a review on 25 Apr

Very good

Recommends the hotel

Location9.0

Rooms7.0

Service7.0

Dining5.0

7.0

cozy room

island vibes

no meals

Beautiful island vibes. Room was cozy, but no on-site meals was disappointing.

0 Helpful

Date of stay: February 20241 nightFamily with childrenQueen Room With Pool View

FAQ about Pony Island Inn

Which landmarks should we visit during our stay at Pony Island Inn hotel?

You can visit British Cemetery, placed approximately 15 minutes' walk from Pony Island Inn hotel or Fish Tale, which is 1.3 km away.

What popular attractions are closest to the Pony Island Inn?

Guests of the Pony Island Inn can visit Ocracoke Island (right by the accommodation), or Teach's Hole Blackbeard Exhibit Gift Shop placed 5 minutes' walk away.

Does Pony Island Inn have a car parking on site?

Guests of Pony Island Inn can take advantage of parking.

What are our dining options during the stay at the Pony Island Inn hotel?

Unfortunately, the Pony Island Inn hotel doesn't have on-site restaurants, but there is a variety of dining venues just outside the property - visit restaurant Helios' Hideaway (450 meters) for the taste of Middle Eastern cuisine or Sorellas Pizza & Pasta (350 meters), which is popular for its Italian dishes.

What is the timeframe for check-in and check-out in the inn?

Guests of the inn can check in from 15:00 to 21:00 and check out from 11:00.

How much does a room at the hotel cost?

The price for a room in the hotel starts at $1087.

What payment methods are available in Pony Island Inn hotel?

At Pony Island Inn hotel, guests can pay using Mastercard, Visa, and American Express as well as other payment methods.

What are the room types offered by the Pony Island Inn?

The Pony Island Inn provides such room types as Queen Room, Deluxe Queen Room, and Standard Queen Room.

Which facilities are included in the rooms at Pony Island Inn hotel?

Each room at Pony Island Inn hotel offers a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, some units feature private bathrooms along with a spa bathtub and guest toiletries.

Is swimming pool available at Pony Island Inn hotel?

Yes, Pony Island Inn hotel features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool.

Tourists from New Zealand often stay at these properties. Consider them for your next trip.

Hampton Inn East Peoria: 6.6 / 10 - Nice | 81 reviews | 135.11 NZ$ / night

La Quinta By Wyndham Cleveland Airport West: 5.8 / 10 - Guest rating | 137 reviews | 141.87 NZ$ / night

Hampton Inn Clinton: 7.9 / 10 - Very good | 55 reviews | 217.87 NZ$ / night

Hampton Inn Alexandria/Old Town: 8.7 / 10 - Great | 79 reviews | 167.20 NZ$ / night

Pony Island Inn - Ocracoke

Location

Rooms

Eat & Drink

Leisure & Business

Rooms and availability

Facilities

Main facilities

Services

Dining

Business

Spa & Leisure

Room view

Room features

Bathroom

Self-catering

Media

Room decor

Essential information about Pony Island Inn

Location

Reviews of Pony Island Inn

great stay but minor issues

Comfortable stay with great location

The location was great with easy access to

FAQ about Pony Island Inn

Tourists from New Zealand often stay at these properties. Consider them for your next trip.